
We host a monthly Accessibility Virtual Reality meetup in Mozilla Hubs. The goal of the meetup is to continuously learn and document best practices for virtual reality accessibility. One thing we’ve learned in our first year of meetings is that the meeting design of space can create accessibility barriers.
When the opportunity to work with technical artist and VR/AR developer Pablo Cárdenas to build a new space for our meetup, we jumped at it. He debuted his new environment at the meetup where he gave a presentation on “Why 97.81% of the World Hasn’t Tried VR Yet.”
Creating the space
Thomas: What was the initial process for creating the space?
Pablo: I created “XRPodium,” an accessible scene for A11yVR, by starting with your initial set of requests for the space. These helped me understand the needs of the users based on your experience hosting these presentations in the VR world.
I also received some references from my Spanish friend Pau Guardiola. These references helped me to think of ways to make this space easy to navigate and user-friendly. We still have things to improve and we’ll keep doing it with attendee feedback. I published “How to create Worlds in Mozilla Hubs (Maya – Substance Painter – Spoke“ to explain my process for creating the space.
In short, I used Maya, Substance Painter, and Spoke to create the virtual world. Maya is 3D computer animation, modeling, simulation, and rendering software. Substance Painter provides the tools for adding texture to 3D assets. Spoke is Mozilla Hubs’ tool for creating the 3D space.
Adding Ramps for Navigation
Thomas: The first assessment of the prototyped world had us realizing that the only way to navigate between levels in the space was to rely on Mozilla Hubs’ teleport feature. Adding ramps into the world ensures the arrow key navigation works correctly for moving between areas in the world.
Could you explain how you added the ramps into the world? Was it difficult? Do you have any advice for other developers and designers of virtual worlds for ramps?

Pablo: It was fairly fast to create the ramps because they are low poly. (This means they have minimal details and don’t require complex geometry.) The process started with a cube in which I tweaked one edge to get a 35-degree angle for the first type of ramps and two edges for the second one.

The most challenging thing about these ramps was the design. That’s because the setting couldn’t have only one type of ramp. If I did that, attendees wouldn’t be able to reach all four floor levels.
So, I had to design a second type of ramp placed in the middle with two sides. This allowed the participants to navigate the whole scene without using the teleport feature. It made the scene more accessible for all audiences.

My advice for developers and designers of virtual worlds is to be aware that some people can’t use more advanced features like teleport. Therefore, we need to design locomotion interactions that are effortless to use.
Considerations for the Speaker
Thomas: Pablo, you added a position for the speaker in the world that allows you to present to the audience and see screen slides. How did that work out for you?

Pablo: This helped me a lot during my live virtual presentation. I felt like I was giving a real-world presentation. It had a virtual podium that worked as a reference of where I was standing.
On this podium, I added another media frame that held my speaker notes. It worked just like my in-person presentations in which I used notes to remember the key points to cover.

Positioning Live Captions
Thomas: How did you decide where to put the captions in relation to the presentation slides. Do you have any recommendations for dimensions for other people interested in building a similar design in their virtual world?
Pablo: I put the placeholders for the slides and captions with the Media Frames tool in Spoke. This locks the media input you assign to them. Only people with admin access can move or change them. I decided that the captions should match the length of the presentation to make it easier to read.
Also, if the caption input is smaller, this media frame automatically adjusts the size to avoid distortion. My recommendation for people building virtual worlds in Mozilla Hubs is to keep the Media Frames slightly separated from each other like in the following image. Otherwise, if they’re too close, the media frames may confuse the media inputs and assign them in the wrong place.

Thomas: When you gave your presentation live at A11yVR, we did some beta testing of the display of captions in the world. We realized that some elements in the environment blocked the captions depending on where the participants’ avatars stood. How did you address this?

Pablo: In some spots on the third floor, the wood fences blocked people’s view. They weren’t able to read the captions. To solve this problem, I made the presentation slides a little smaller and removed the fences causing the issue.
It’s worth mentioning that we didn’t notice this until an attendee pointed it out. That’s why it’s very important to have people inside these virtual worlds and to keep iterating based on feedback to improve the user experience.

Share Your Thoughts
To review an example of the world in action check out Pablo’s Presentation from A11yVR.
Transcript: Why 97.81% of the World Hasn't Tried VR Yet - Pablo Cardenas
Good afternoon. Good morning, or Good night. It depends on which part of the world you are attending today. My name is Pablo Cardenas, and I would like to welcome you to XR Podium.
That's how I call this virtual world I created, with Thomas Logan's help to make it accessible. And with some feedback from an Argentinan friend, Pau Guardiola. I would like to thank both of them for collaborating with me to make this possible. And if you guys, as Thomas said, have any comments of our environment, please let us know because we want to keep improving accessibility and make this enjoyable for everyone.
So first, I would like to give a short introduction of who I am, as well as my professional career and my studies. I love cooking, playing chess, diving with wonderful sea creatures, and taking pictures of anything that is interesting for me. Everything is started when I was a kid, and I wanted to get paid for being working in front of a computer. And the journey started in 2015 with an edX course, Introduction to Game Design.
Then, with the guidance of my brother, I started my bachelor's in Animation and Digital Arts at Monterey Institute of Technology and Higher Education. As I wanted to start creating virtual worlds and creatures as soon as possible, at the same time I studied 3D Design and Digital Animation at the University of Advanced Technologies. Then I worked for plus one year as a Motion Capture Technician and Developer at XRTales. And at the same time, I worked part time as Unity Mobile Developer at SignAmy.
Then in 2020, I won a scholarship for plus 80% to study VR/AR Design and Development in the Vancouver Film School. Right after my graduation I started working for Lifelike & Believable Animation Design as a Technical Artist using Unreal Engine. And this is my current position. Now that you know a little bit about me, let's start with the conference.
So, about 97.81% of the world hasn't tried VR yet. You may be wondering, how did I come up with those numbers? Well, in the world, we currently have around 7.7 billion people and only around 171 million VR users. This shows that only around 2.20% of the world's population is a VR user.
So first, I would like to speak a little bit about the different types of VR headsets that we have at the moment. So, we have right now, mobile VR headsets that are basically headsets that we can use with our phones. So, we have a lot of potential users because we only need something that holds it to your face. Like Google cardboard, for example.
And we can try some VR experiences with three degrees of freedom. And we also have standalone VR headsets, for example, the Oculus Quest. These headsets have their own computing units inside of the headset, and the graphical units too. So these headsets are able to handle mid range VR experiences.
And then we have the Desktop VR. So this VR headset is the one that has less users as it requires people to be plugged in into a high end PC, or medium range PC. Pablo Cardenas So let's dive a little bit more in detail about the mobile VR. We have some pros and cons about this one.
The best thing about mobile VR is that it's low cost, and it has more potential users as almost everyone has a mobile phone, and it doesn't require a high end PC, and it is very handy, as it fits into our pockets. The cons is that the quality of the VR experiences is low, it has less frames per second, and it is only three degrees of freedom. This means that it only tracks the rotation of the headset in the three axes, but it doesn't track any translation.
It also has one bad thing about notifications that they can show in front of the content. This is very bad because this can break the immersion. We also are constrained to the temperature and time, because our mobile phones can get very hot by trying to render these VR experiences. We also have a battery limit as our cell phones can run out of battery.
Now let's talk a little bit about the standalone VR. For Standalone VR, these headsets are very easy to use as they work out of the box. So, you just have to buy this headset, make sure that it is charged, and log in into your account, and you can start using it right out of the box. These don't require any high end PC, as they have their own computing units inside of the headset.
These headsets can be found in three degrees of freedom as well as in six degrees of freedom. And they're very handy, as they can fit into like any backpack. The cons is that this is still in a mid to low quality VR, because they don't have as much power as a computer. They are also constrained as to temperature and time.
For example, in the Oculus Go, if you play more than 30 minutes in a row of VR Zombies game, it turns off automatically because it gets too hot. And we're also constrained to the battery limit. And now for the desktop VR. And this is the VR headset that can give us the most quality.
And all of them are with six degrees of freedom so they can track your rotation and translation from controllers and headset. And some of them are handy. Some of them are not, such as the HTC Vive, because you need to carry also the lighthouses and the sensors that are on top of the lighthouses. And these headsets require high end PC, and the frames per second that you see in these headsets, it's basically depending on how are the components of your computer.
If you have better components, you are going to be able to reach more frames per second. It requires a little bit more complex setup as you need to bind your controllers, and scan your area. Some of them require external sensor as the HTC Vive, or the Valve Index as I was saying. So, we're going to evaluate the price of these headsets.
I like to call this chart the quality against price chart, because for example the mobile phones, we can find the cheapest ones at $100, and we can also find a Google Cardboard at $5. But we are not going to have as much quality as with a standalone, and with a standalone, we are not going to have as much quality as with a PC VR. For standalone, we have like around $299 price.
This is what Oculus Quest 2 is at the moment. And for the PC VR, the price just blows up like for around $2,000, because we need the headset, and we also need to have a mid end PC to high end PC to run these experiences. So, my investigation came around from 195 countries, where we can see in this chart that China and India are the countries that have more people. And, as for my investigation, some amazing facts came out of it.
Like there is some countries that have a higher minimum wage, as for example, Denmark, that has around $6,000 of minimum wage. And on the other side there is, for example, Venezuela, that has $4.6 as the minimum wage in a month. So, this is why the market of this 3 types of VR headsets is very limited. But for example, for the mobile VR headset, we have a lot more potential users.
Out of those 195 countries, we have 156 countries that are able to pay this price and acquire mobile VR hardware. So I found out that for the standalone VR, we have a little bit less potential users. And like there are only 88 countries that can purchase these VR headsets. For the PC VR the number of potential users really drops down, as we need to buy also a PC.
So, there are only 17 countries around the world that are able and capable to buy this equipment. Now let's talk a little bit about how VR can help people with disabilities. For this one, I couldn't make a very extensive investigation. I just could find 49 countries, as the data was very hard to find.
And this reflected that There are three ways that we can help people with disabilities One of the things that we can do is help them with rehabilitation. How? We can help them to perform certain movements, that their therapist may want them to do in order to get better, by introducing a fun part, like a character that they should follow, or story that they have to be doing, as they perform these movements.
And the second thing that we can help them, is we can help them to work without leaving the comfort of their houses, because, for example, in this image, we can see that if this person was disabled, for example, he has to be in his wheelchair., and with his wheelchair, he wouldn't be able to reach the top rack. So, if he's controlling this robot, this robot has the ability to go to any of these places.
And this person could be able to work from the comfort of his house, with the help of the VR. Something as well we can help them is with entertainment. Because we know that, if people that have disabilities have a very good time, they are going to be happy. And their recovery could be better, because emotional stability also helps people to recover faster.
I would like to thank everyone for your time today. Thank you for being here. And if you have any questions, I'll be more than happy to answer them. And also feel free to reach out to me.
There are my social media and my email address. Thomas Logan Great. Thank you, Pablo. This is excellent.
I'll start off with an initial question. And then we'll be looking on the YouTube, and here in the chat, for comments and questions. So, just to start off, do you think that a 3DOF experience is a good introduction for getting more people involved around the world, you know, from a starting point? Pablo Cardenas Well, I think that that is a very good start point for VR, but it is not a very engaged experience, because we are not able to perform certain movements in terms of translation, we are just constrained to where we looking at, and our functionalities are less.
But it could be a very good introduction for someone that hasn't tried VR yet. Thomas Logan Thank you. Thomas Logan Anyone here in the room have any questions? h4rry I have a question.
So, you mentioned that there's just a few people that we can reach with the current VR setups we have. So, what is the next thing we need to do to reach more people? Like, are there any plans? Or what are you suggesting to reach more people?
Pablo Cardenas There is something that I'm trying to do to help users that haven't tried VR yet to try it for the first time. One of my visions is to get an Epic Mega Grant for this, and start making VR experiences sold to companies. For example, I have one that I am trying to sell to Coca Cola. And this one, I am planning to place in a park, or some place that some people can see that someone is trying a VR headset, and they can go for free and try it.
And, at the end, this is like a brand activation for Coca Cola, and a lot of people can get involved into trying VR for the first time. h4rry Is there a plan for any country or specific place that we can look for? Pablo Cardenas I was thinking about Canada. But I don't know yet in which country will this happen.
It will probably happen in Ecuador. This all depends in how much time my visa paperwork will take, and if I get these Epic Mega Grant approved, and also if any company is willing to do their marketing campaign by this mode. h4rry Sounds like a great idea. Inviting more companies to the VR world.
Thank you. Pablo Cardenas Thank you for your question. It was really good. Thomas Logan Do you have any countries that are like doing more in VR than others?
Or, you know, when you looked at those percentages? Is there a certain country? Or anything interesting from a specific country for a VR initiative? Pablo Cardenas Um, no, I couldn't find something that is specific about how many VR users were in each country, but that will be something that I will look at, because it sounds really interesting for me.
Thomas Logan Is Facebook's recent decision to make all Quest users require FB login going to negatively or positively impact -- on the updated feature update of VR? What do you think about Facebook and Quest? Pablo Cardenas Well, I think that I've met a lot of people that, they don't like this idea of logging into Facebook account. So, maybe these will impact a little bit into these people, that they don't like to have their social media involved with their games.
But, for most of the people, this couldn't be an issue unless you're very concerned about your privacy and your settings. Thomas Logan I recommend to make a fake Facebook account if you're gonna get a Quest. That's what I do, personally, because why give them that information? And, I want to end with saying thank you again to Pablo for the excellent presentation tonight.
Thanks everyone. Thank you. Thank you for having me and for bringing me a little bit of your time today.
We hope this interview provided you with insights and consideration for creating accessible virtual worlds. Please join us at one of the A11yVR meetups. When you do, please feel free to share your feedback with us on the A11yVR Meetup page.