
Katsutoshi Tsuji joined our virtual reality (VR) accessibility research and provided a lot of insightful feedback. You can read what he shared in Virtual Reality Accessibility: 11 Things We Learned from Blind Users After he tried the Equal Entry virtual reality environment, we interviewed him to gain insights on virtual reality from his perspective as a person who is blind.
Transcript: What Does a Blind Person Think about VR? | Interview with Katsutoshi san
My name is Tsuji Katsutoshi, and I am congenitally blind. I have been using a screen reader to live and work for about 30 years. I use a white cane to get around. I like computer games. I especially like Street Fighter.
I work for smart HR as an accessibility specialist. In Japan, there are many procedures that can only be done on paper. I want to digitize them. My mission is to make it possible for people with disabilities to do paperwork.
Thanks for having me today. Today, we had Katsutoshi san test our Equal Entry VR environment. We did a test to see if VR can be used by a blind person. First, have you ever used VR before?
No. This was my first time. So did you know what VR was like or have you heard anything about VR? Well, I had an image of sound moving around in various directions around my body.
I was surprised it was very natural and not too different from everyday life. I imagined it would be something like sound approaching me There are such games where the sound comes at you. Various games like rhythm games. You might be wondering why you had to wear this heavy headset, Because VR is such a visual experience, A lot of people tend to wonder, "Why should I do anything for blind people in VR?"
So we are working hard to do more VR accessibility research. Do you have any ideas on what you would want to do in VR? What I want to try the most is ... I want to simulate going to a new place.
For example, In the Equal Entry VR, there was a conference room. While mixing the sounds of the actual place, I want to simulate walking in the place. I think it would be helpful when I actually went to that place. Ah, I never thought of that but, When I think about it, I check Google Maps before going to places, For example, when I drive, I check where the car park is and what the roads are like.
Same thing, right? Exactly. Landmarks for blind people are, for example, let me see... At stations, there are sounds like a ding-dong and also...
It is getting harder to notice recently but, there are places where they play their unique songs or sound For example, at McDonald's, they play their own music. At Big Camera, home appliance retail, they play their own song. Something like that. Mixing the sound of the specific place.
I think it would be so interesting to make a simulation of visiting a place. I see. That is such a good idea. It is a great reference for what we are going to build.
- We will think about it! - Yes. So today, you tested our VR environment. How was it? Let us know your general impression.
I have used controllers only for games in the past. This was the first time for me to use controllers for somethng practical. So it was really interesting. You know what I mean? Like...
The actual products and... like at a convenience store, I have thought that I should not touch products before I buy. However, to be honest, I want to know what kind of products there are. That is sort of why it might be a good use of VR like learning where in a convenience store, what kind of products there are.
If I could know that, I think I would enjoy shopping more. I see. That opens up a lot of opportunities. Yes. If I ask the store staff, let's say, ...
"I want oolong tea," they bring me the Oolong tea. But they never talk about the products next to Oolong tea. They don't say things like, "There is rooibos tea today." To know that I would have to...
look around the shelves. While a sighted person can take the products that they have never seen before if they find it curious, so you are saying you can only ask for what you know. Exactly. So, I think that VR can allow us to enjoy shopping more.
That is what I thought. I think that opens a lot of possibilities. As I said earlier... Most people think of it as a visual experience, so people tend to disregard blind people when it comes to VR.
I am glad that we learned a lot today. The idea is so interesting and it is quite an eye-opener. Yes. I think that blind people are...
we need to have a clear goal when going shopping. We are not good at window shopping. For example, we don't think like, "Oh, there is a new cake in the show window" We are not good at browsing. We are more like, "I want to eat the chestnuts cake" Something like that.
We only do things with a clear goal. So, we don't really think like "Oh, that strawberry cake looks delicious." That is why I think VR opens opportunities. Like people say, broadening the horizon right?
Exactly right. So you can experience more new things. I think so. That was very interesting. Thank you very much today.
Thank you. See you next time! So This was an interview after Equal Entry VR testing. Thanks for watching.
Have you ever used or had any thoughts on virtual reality?
This was my first time using virtual reality. I had this image of sound moving around my body in various directions, but I was surprised at how subtle it was. The experience was not very different from everyday life. I had imagined that there would be a lot of sounds coming at me and many things happening at the same time.
What would you want to do in virtual reality?
I think it would be nice if I could visit a new place before I actually go there. For example, the virtual reality environment I tested announced how many feet there were to the door of a conference room.
If you can add ambient sounds of the actual place and make it sound like you’re actually walking there, that would be a good simulation of going there. I think it helps when you physically go to the place. For the visually impaired, landmarks are, for example, the sound of a train station, like some machine going ding-dong.
It’s hard to tell these days. I think it depends on the store. For example, in the old days, McDonald’s would play their own music. In the past, you could recognize McDonald’s because the McDonald’s song played. Another example is Big Camera — a consumer electronics retailer chain in Japan — playing their theme song. I think it would be interesting to mix the sounds of those places and simulate the physical visit.
What was your impression of the Equal Entry virtual reality environment?
I’ve only really used hand controllers for gaming, so this is the first time I’ve tried something that I could use for practical reasons. The convenience store is very interesting. I have always thought that it is better not to touch convenience store products before buying them. At the same time, I want to know what kind of products are sold there. I think it would be fun to shop if I know what items are sold in convenience stores.
For example, if you ask for a bottle of oolong tea, they give you one. However, they don’t tell you what products are next to oolong tea. If there is rooibos tea next to it, I would not notice. So, I think virtual reality can make it fun to go shopping. Usually, visually impaired people need to have a purpose when we go shopping. We are not good at window shopping.
Let’s say, for instance, I don’t really think about things like “Oh, there’s a new cake in the show window.” I am more like, “I want that maroon cake, so I go get one.” We need a clear goal when we go out and buy something. I can’t be like “Oh, this strawberry cake looks delicious.” I believe it will open up a lot of possibilities.
About Katsutoshi Tsuji
Katsutoshi has congenital total blindness and has used screen readers every day for over 30 years. He uses a white cane to walk around. He likes to play computer games such as “Street Fighter.” Katsutoshi works for SmartHR as an accessibility specialist. In Japan, there is a lot of paperwork that requires physical paper. He is working to take advantage of technologies to make them accessible to people with disabilities.
Virtual Reality (VR) Accessibility Consulting Services
Our years of experience working with virtual reality and being speakers on the topic have given us a unique perspective when it comes to consulting on VR projects. If you’d like to innovate in the accessibility of VR please, please contact us to discuss how we can help you.